Andrea McCardle Will Play Miss Hannigan in Annie Gotham Rex 6 years ago Andrea McCardle Will Play Miss Hannigan in Annie Broadway’s original Annie returns to the hit musical in New Jersey. Share: Annie to Return to the West End, Starring Miranda Hart as Miss HanniganDateFebruary 16, 2017In relation toPlaybillLise Davidsen in Elektra, Barbara Hannigan in Supernova, More Heading to Lincoln CenterDateJanuary 30, 2020In relation toPlaybillLook Back at Andrea McArdle and the Original Cast of Annie on BroadwayDateApril 20, 2018In relation toPlaybill