Check Out the New Cast of The Play That Goes Wrong Gotham Rex 7 years ago Check Out the New Cast of The Play That Goes Wrong The Tony-winning production continues at the Lyceum Theatre. Share: Watch The Play That Goes Wrong Cast in Green Goes Wrong: Paper ConservationDateApril 19, 2019In relation toPlaybillFull London Cast Announced for Mischief Theatre’s Magic Goes WrongDateJuly 26, 2019In relation toPlaybillBroadway’s The Play That Goes Wrong Will Welcome New CastDateSeptember 14, 2017In relation toPlaybill